A few months ago I posted a review with swatches on four of the new NYX Butter Lipsticks in Razzle, Hot Tamale, Big Cherry and Pops. Â Since I loved them so much, I decided to pick up a few more and placed an order on NYX’s website for Fizzies, Cotton Candy, Hubba Bubba, Hunk and Bit of Honey. Â After using these the last couple of months, I decided I would do some swatches in case anyone was interested in the shades I purchased… especially since when I ordered them, I expected them to be a bit different then how they arrived. Â Some of the shades were much lighter and darker than I had expected.
The butter lipsticks retail for $6.00 on NYX’s website and come in 22 shades. Â Just like I stated in my first review, the NYX Butter Lipsticks feel great on the lips and are moisturizing. Â But I think some of these shades feel a bit different on the lips and when it comes to coverage, the lighter shades seem to sink into the lines of my lips unlike the original four colors I tried out.
In the swatch photo above, you can see that Hubba Bubba has a slight frost to it – since it does have a light amount of shimmer in the lipstick. Â Because of this, I was a little disappointed at how my lips looked when I used this shade and I do not use it often. Â On the website – Cotton Candy and Hubba Bubba lend for a more wearable shade so I was surprised to see it so Barbie Pink when they arrived. Â I do like Fizzies, though it is not a shade I will use often – it does match my skin tone and Hunk and Bit of Honey are also ones I enjoy too.
Have you tried the NYX Butter lipsticks? Â While I do love some of these new ones I received, I think the only favorites out of this bunch would be Hunk and Fizzies. Â The others just seem too white for me to wear on its own… but hey, that is what gloss and liner is for. Â I’ll still find a way to make it work. Â If you want to see swatches on the other Butter lipsticks I reviewed – don’t forget to click here. Â If you tried any of these lipsticks and have favorites – please comment below and let me know, I would love to check them out and see if they will match me.
Have a wonderful week!
40 Comments
Beautiful shades! I have a few here that I picked up at Ulta, I think it’s time I tried them out!
Ooh – I can’t wait to see which ones you got and that you like… I’m so excited to see. Hurry and try them woman. lol 😉
HUNK looks gorgeous on you!!
thank you love 😉
I haven’t tried these, I am still stuck on the mattes, which I do love from NYX
Ooh – I love the mattes from NYX – tea rose is my favorite 🙂
Hunk and Fizzies look great on you! Those are the two I’d pick from your arm swatches, too!!
thank you Judy – I love those two, they are awesome. 😉
I love Hunk and Bit o’ Honey
I love hunk – my fav 🙂
I am going back and forth on these lipsticks. I will probably buy one or two, eventually but just from swatches, I am not sure which ones.
I wish I didn’t have to order them online, but none of my local stores have them. That is why I ended up with 2 shades almost completely similar and they don’t match me at all – the website colors are off. You would look so awesome in the red or orange… Hot Tamale or big cherry – I swatched in my older post. They would look so awesome on you 😉
I love the way Fizzies looks on you!
thank you Kat 😉
I love Hunk – it was the first butter lippie I bought. I think Fizzies is pretty, too, but the others are too light for me. You are the Queen of Layering, though – if anyone can make it work, you can! 🙂
Yes – the others are super light for me too…. lmao – yes, I am sure I can make it work. I like blending hunk with the pinks… it is nice 😉
Very pretty shades! Loving Fizzies!
they are and I am liking that one too 😉
Fizzies looks amazing on you!
I love that color – it is gorgeous for Spring and Summer 😉 thank you
These are just so durn buttery! I hope they continue to make more colors.
me too – I would love them to make a violet purple with pink hue… I have been dying to get a shade like that from my favorite brands. 😉
Those look gorgeous on you!
thank you Kelly 😉
Hunk is definitely my pick from the batch. It looks incredible.
it is one of my favorites… I tone it down a bit with a soft pink gloss but it is awesome regardless 😉
Oh wow… those shades are so pigmented!
they are really nice 😉
Hubba Bubba is very, very pretty! I love it!
it is such a sweet shade but I have to mix it with other shades so I don’t look ghostly. I think you would rock it out Kendra 😉
Fizzies is right up my alley ! So pretty and perfect for spring
it really is – I am enjoying it. 😉
I noticed the lighter shades are a bit harder to wear. To make them more wearable I blend them in with a darker lip liner.
they really are and I’m disappointed but I have been blending with lip liner and topping with gloss and it has worked. 🙂
Yes – it really is a good universal shade and I love that it is perfect for Spring and summer
Hunk is my win too 😉
Which 2 do you have? I wish it was easier to order them online… shipping from NYX is crazy to Hawaii.
Pigmented but moisturizing. I do love them for that and Hunk… ooh yes, that is a nice one. 😉
Hunk looks great on you!
thank you love – I think it’s my favorite.